London Aesthetics Forum

London Aesthetics Forum
24 April 2019, 4.00pm - 6.00pm
Room 246, Second Floor, Senate House, Malet Street, London WC1E 7HU


Wittgenstein and Musical Formalism: A Case Revisited


Hanne Appelqvist (University of Helsinki)



This paper defends a formalist interpretation of Wittgenstein’s later thought on music by comparing it with Eduard Hanslick’s musical formalism. In doing so, it returns to a disagreement I have had with Bela Szabados who, in his book Wittgenstein as a Philosophical Tone-Poet, claims that the attribution of formalism obscures the role that music played in the development of Wittgenstein’s thought. In the paper, I scrutinize the four arguments Szabados present to defend his claim, pertaining to alleged differences between Wittgenstein and Hanslick on their accounts of theory, beauty, rules, and the broader significance of music. I argue that in each case the similarities between Wittgenstein’s and Hanslick’s respective views outshine possible differences. Ultimately, I argue that instead of rendering music a marginal phenomenon suited for mere entertainment, formalism – as presented by Hanslick and Wittgenstein, whom I read as influenced by Kant’s aesthetics – underscores music’s ability to show fundamental features of reality and our relation to it. Music does this precisely by being treated as a sensuous yet structured medium that is irreducible to any conceptually determined domain.



The London Aesthetics Forum (LAF) is a Forum of the Institute of Philosophy at the University of London’s School of Advanced Study. With lectures on topics in aesthetics and philosophy of art, LAF aims to stimulate philosophical reflection on art. Our events are free and open to all.

View our programme of events, sign up for the newsletter, or browse our archives and podcasts.

Now available, episodes of Aesthetics Bites, a collaboration between the London Aesthetics Forum and Philosophy Bites (made possible by a grant from the British Society of Aesthetics).

We are generously sponsored by the British Society of Aesthetics

bsa_logo_hrz_bw_high (in white box)




Institute of Philsophy
020 7664 4865